How to Enforce Freight Payment Agreements Legally

Carriers deliver freight every day based on trust that payment will follow—but when that trust is broken, legal action may be necessary. Enforcing freight payment agreements isn’t just about chasing down invoices—it’s about using legal tools strategically and in compliance with FMCSA rules. In this guide, we explain how to enforce freight payment agreements legally, maximize recoveries, and protect your trucking operation from future non-payment issues.

Why Freight Payment Agreements Fail

Even when agreements are clear, payment disputes can arise due to:

• Brokers withholding funds due to alleged delivery issues
• Misunderstandings over rates or accessorial charges
• Failure to document delivery or proof of service
• Brokers becoming insolvent or disappearing

When brokers refuse to pay, it’s critical to take the right legal steps—while maintaining your FMCSA compliance.

Legal Foundations of Freight Payment Agreements

Whether you’re working with a contract, a rate confirmation, or a broker-carrier agreement, freight payment terms are governed by contract law and federal transportation regulations.

To legally enforce payment:

• There must be a valid agreement (written or confirmed electronically)
• You must have fulfilled your delivery obligations
• You must have proof of performance (e.g., signed BOL, POD, GPS logs)

Strong documentation is key to proving breach of contract and recovering what you’re owed.

Step-by-Step: How to Enforce a Freight Payment Agreement

1. Review the Original Agreement

Start by reviewing your rate confirmation or broker-carrier agreement. Confirm the payment terms, rate, accessorial charges, and required documentation. Look for any clauses that could be used to delay or reduce payment.

2. Document All Communications

Gather all records, including:

• Email threads or text messages
• Load tenders or dispatch logs
• Delivery receipts and BOLs
• Invoices and payment follow-ups

The clearer your paper trail, the harder it is for the broker to dispute your claim.

3. Send a Formal Demand Letter

Before filing a bond claim or lawsuit, send a legally compliant demand letter that:

• Clearly states the amount owed
• Includes supporting documents
• Sets a final deadline for payment
• Notes your intent to escalate if ignored

Most brokers respond once legal language and evidence are presented in writing.

4. File a Bond Claim

If the broker fails to respond or pay, the next step is to file a claim against their FMCSA bond (BMC-84 or BMC-85).

• Find the broker’s bond provider via FMCSA’s Licensing & Insurance portal
• Submit your demand letter, rate confirmation, invoice, and delivery proof
• Include any communications that support your position

Bond claims must be filed promptly—typically within 12 months of the load date.

5. Pursue Legal Action If Needed

If the bond is insufficient or denied, you may need to sue the broker for breach of contract. Legal remedies include:

• Filing in small claims or civil court
• Requesting summary judgment with your documentation
• Collecting through garnishment or property liens

Working with a transportation attorney ensures compliance and improves your recovery chances.

How FMCSA Compliance Supports Your Legal Enforcement

Brokers often look for reasons to challenge your claim. If your authority is inactive, your insurance has lapsed, or you didn’t follow Hours of Service rules, they may refuse payment.

To avoid this:

• Keep your FMCSA filings current
• Ensure all delivery documentation is complete and signed
• Use electronic records to prove compliance and load completion

Legal enforcement only works when your business is legally sound.

Pro Tips for Avoiding Future Payment Disputes

• Always use written agreements or email confirmations for each load
• Set payment expectations upfront (net terms, late fees, etc.)
• Keep consistent delivery documentation, including photos or GPS logs
• Perform credit checks on new brokers before hauling
• Track payments weekly and follow up on overdue invoices immediately

By tightening your billing and documentation process, you reduce your legal exposure and payment delays.

FAQs About Enforcing Freight Payment Agreements

Do I need a written contract to enforce payment?
No, but written confirmation (e.g., email, rate sheet) makes enforcement far easier and legally solid.

Can I charge late fees?
Yes, if the original agreement or invoice terms include them. Always document these terms in writing.

What if the broker is no longer in business?
You can still file a bond claim or pursue legal action against affiliated entities or guarantors.

Is it worth suing over a small invoice?
If the amount is under your state’s small claims limit, it may be resolved quickly without an attorney. Larger amounts usually benefit from legal representation.

Legal Support When You Need It

Freight Collection Solutions helps carriers recover unpaid invoices through contract enforcement, bond claims, and legal action. Our team ensures every step follows FMCSA regulations, helping you protect your business while getting paid faster.

Contact Us Today: